ADVERTISEMENT
To prepare seriously, Montgomery studied at the American Academy of Dramatic Arts in New York City. There, she received classical training that emphasized restraint, vocal control, movement, and psychological depth. This foundation became one of her defining strengths. Unlike many performers of her era who relied primarily on charm, Montgomery treated acting as a disciplined, technical art. That approach later set her apart on television, where subtlety often carried more power than volume.
Her early career unfolded in the 1950s through television anthology dramas, which were then considered a proving ground for serious actors. She appeared in programs such as Studio One, Kraft Television Theatre, Playhouse 90, and The Twilight Zone. These performances earned her early recognition for emotional precision and intelligence. She often portrayed women facing moral conflict, internal struggle, or psychological tension—roles that demanded control rather than exaggeration.
Her personal life during these years was marked by transition. She married four times, but none of those early relationships provided lasting stability. It was later, in her long-term partnership with actor Robert Foxworth, that she found enduring companionship. Though they never married, their relationship became a source of emotional balance and support, particularly during the later stages of her career.
The turning point that defined Montgomery’s public legacy came in 1964 when she was cast as Samantha Stephens in Bewitched. Created by Sol Saks, the series centered on a witch who marries a mortal man and chooses suburban domestic life, suppressing her supernatural abilities to fit societal expectations. While the premise was whimsical, Montgomery played it with sincerity and depth.
Under her interpretation, Samantha was never a novelty. She was intelligent, empathetic, and quietly assertive—often more emotionally perceptive and practical than the men around her, including her husband, Darrin. Without overtly challenging social norms, Montgomery infused the character with subtle authority. Samantha’s restraint, rather than her magic, became the show’s emotional core.
Bewitched ran for eight seasons, from 1964 to 1972, becoming one of the most successful sitcoms of its era. Montgomery received multiple Emmy nominations, but the show’s cultural impact extended beyond awards. Over time, Samantha Stephens came to be seen as a symbolic figure—a woman negotiating autonomy, power, and identity during a decade of major social change. Montgomery later acknowledged that the role resonated more deeply than anyone initially anticipated.
Despite the show’s success, Montgomery was careful not to let it define her limits. Even during Bewitched, she continued taking dramatic roles in programs like Alfred Hitchcock Presents, consistently demonstrating range and resisting typecasting. When the series ended in 1972, she faced a crossroads familiar to many actors closely associated with a single iconic role.
Rather than clinging to familiarity, Montgomery chose reinvention.
The rise of made-for-television films in the 1970s offered her a new creative path, and she embraced it fully. Her post-Bewitched career became defined by serious, socially relevant roles that demanded emotional risk. One of her most significant performances came in 1974 with A Case of Rape, in which she portrayed a woman navigating the aftermath of sexual assault and a deeply flawed legal system. At a time when such topics were rarely addressed openly, Montgomery’s restrained, honest performance earned widespread acclaim and an Emmy nomination.
In 1975, she delivered what many critics still consider her most daring work in The Legend of Lizzie Borden. Rather than offering a clear verdict on guilt or innocence, Montgomery leaned into ambiguity, using silence and psychological tension to unsettling effect. The performance was fearless and complex, cementing her reputation as one of television’s most formidable dramatic actresses.
ADVERTISEMENT
