ADVERTISEMENT
Just weeks later, he answered an open casting call for a film called Class. Surrounded by hundreds of hopefuls, he assumed nothing would come of it. Instead, he was cast opposite Jacqueline Bisset in a provocative role that instantly put him on Hollywood’s radar. One week he was a failed college student; the next, he was a working actor with industry attention. When NYU offered to let him return and count the film as independent study, he declined. He was already moving forward.
The mid-1980s turned him into a cultural phenomenon. Films like St. Elmo’s Fire, Pretty in Pink, Mannequin, and Weekend at Bernie’s cemented his status as a defining figure of the era. He was grouped with the so-called Brat Pack, a label that came with fame, scrutiny, and a narrative he never quite fit. While others leaned into excess, McCarthy recoiled from attention. He was introverted, anxious, and deeply uncomfortable with celebrity culture, even as it elevated him.
What began as social drinking escalated as fame intensified. Alcohol became a tool—liquid confidence that quieted his fears and gave him a temporary sense of control. On screen, he was praised for sensitivity and emotional depth. Off screen, he was often hungover, disconnected, and unraveling. He later admitted that during some of his most beloved performances, he was barely holding himself together, physically and emotionally.
Substances offered escape, but at a cost. While he avoided heavy drug use on set, he didn’t escape addiction. Fame amplified access and isolation in equal measure, creating the perfect conditions for self-destruction. By the late 1980s, the pressure and internal conflict became impossible to ignore.
In 1989, just before filming Weekend at Bernie’s, McCarthy stopped drinking abruptly and withdrew from the social scene. For someone already comfortable with solitude, isolation wasn’t the hardest part. Staying sober was. A relapse during a later project triggered several years of decline, culminating in a physical and emotional collapse that forced him to confront reality. At 29, he entered rehab and committed fully to recovery.
That decision marked the true turning point of his life.
Sobriety didn’t just save him—it redirected him. As Hollywood’s obsession with youth shifted elsewhere, McCarthy quietly reinvented himself. He moved behind the camera, directing episodes of major television series and discovering a sense of authorship he’d never felt as an actor-for-hire. His work expanded into prestige television, where his sensitivity translated into strong storytelling instincts.
Then came an unexpected second act: writing.
McCarthy found a new voice as a travel writer, earning recognition for deeply personal, reflective essays published in outlets like National Geographic Traveler and Men’s Journal. In 2010, he was named Travel Journalist of the Year, a title that surprised many but made perfect sense to him. Acting and writing, he explained, were simply different forms of storytelling. Both required presence, vulnerability, and honesty.
ADVERTISEMENT
